Flexible and stretchable electronics require both sensing elements and stretching-insensitive electrical connections. Conductive polymer composites and liquid metals are highly deformable but change their conductivity upon elongation and/or contain rare metals. Solid conductive composites are limited in mechanoelectrical properties and are often combined with macroscopic Kirigami structures, but their use is limited by geometrical restraints. Here, we introduce “Electrofluids”, concentrated conductive particle suspensions with transient particle contacts that flow under shear that bridge the gap between classic solid composites and liquid metals. We show how Carbon Black (CB) forms large agglomerates when using incompatible solvents that reduce the electrical percolation threshold by 1 order of magnitude compared to more compatible solvents, where CB is well-dispersed. We analyze the correlation between stiffness and electrical conductivity to create a figure of merit of first electrofluids. Sealed elastomeric tubes containing different types of electrofluids were characterized under uniaxial tensile strain, and their electrical resistance was monitored. We found a dependency of the piezoresistivity with the solvent compatibility. Electrofluids enable the rational design of sustainable soft electronics components by simple solvent choice and can be used both as sensor and electrode materials, as we demonstrate.